How to prove marketing effectiveness with certainty

Posted on April 9, 2021

Updated on January 31, 2022

7 min read time

Marketing effectiveness is when your marketing spend reflects positively on the value of your business - boosting your reputation, relationships or revenue.  


If you were trying to get to an unknown location, you would use GPS to guide you. The same applies to your marketing, as without a tried and tested method to determine effectiveness, you can find yourself blindly going through the motions, without knowing if your actions are helping or hindering your brand.   


Why is it important to prove marketing effectiveness?  


Marketers have traditionally had a tough job convincing external and internal parties to invest in their actions. Knowing how to prove marketing effectiveness is crucial for Brand Management, as providing tangible financial evidence that certain actions make ‘X’ amount of impact, is a need for any Brand Manager, when the time comes to convince senior stakeholders of the value in their continued investment. In short, proving your marketing actions is the gateway to having the right people on your side, a higher level of budget allocation, and future campaigns running seamlessly.  


As a lot of marketing is based on the future, ‘If you do X and Y, you’ll see a positive return in a 6 months time’ pitching, it can be difficult to get internal and external stakeholders on board. This is often the case with the C-Suite, who spend in a more holistic way and are therefore sceptical of investing a large portion of money in one area, without a clear idea of what they’ll get in return.  


Marketing proof will enable marketers to: 

  • Convince stakeholders, internal colleagues and agencies of the need for marketing. When done well, this can encourage these parties to allocate more budget towards marketing. 
  • Be confident investment is going into the right areas and will directly contribute to the business’s growth. 
  • Empower the marketing teams to feel more confident that what they do day-to-day adds value and brings more money into the business. 
  • Collect and gather useful intelligence to use to improve future campaigns.
  • Create a more fluid company structure that is coordinated and collaborative, working together to achieve objectives.
  • Increase sales and brand awareness and bring more customers into the business. 


Methods to prove marketing effectiveness


When making your case to your seniors, focus on revenue, customers and profit, as well as how your actions will further their goals. Marketing needs to be seen as an investment, rather than a cost. To achieve this, present yourself as an enabler, through concrete intelligence tied to your company objectives.  


Revert back to your core business aims. What is the most important thing for your company? Is their main goal to steal market share, disrupt the category or drive penetration for the business? Whatever the goal, marketers need to have a firm hold of it to ensure their actions are aligned with the company's mission. Without a clear idea of what your company is trying to achieve, you will struggle to prove value in your marketing actions. 


Here are some metrics and methods to use to prove marketing effectiveness:  

  • Return on Investment (ROI) is a metric that by weighing up the profitability of an investment, is a good indicator to judge the efficiency of your actions, as it shows a direct correlation between activity and sales. 
  • Social Metrics provide a quick, surface-level view impression of a campaign. Through social metrics, you can detect engagement, follower count and reach, and see how well an ad, post or story performs amongst your target audience. 
  • Post-campaign analytic reports are ad hoc reports that take place after a campaign has landed. They are used to analyze the success of a specific marketing venture, like a product launch, ad or event. 

The method you choose to use will vary depending on your company’s core objective. If you’re looking to increase your reach, you might prefer to use social platforms to boost awareness, but if driving sales is your goal, ROI might be your best bet. 


Unfortunately, each of these methods have limitations so their intelligence must not be taken at face value.  


ROI is a commonly used measure across many businesses, but it cannot accurately account for the effectiveness of marketing spend, as it’s too focused on the short-term and on easy wins. To achieve a high ROI, you need to spend less, and for a low ROI you spend more. That’s why ROI is so often thought of as a measure of a company’s efficiency rather than effectiveness, as it doesn’t look at gross profit but instead, at the short-term financial losses. 


Typically with marketing actions it takes time to see results. That’s why ROI won’t be beneficial for proving your marketing effectiveness, as it will simply highlight to the company where they can expect financial losses, without taking into account the huge amount they stand to gain, such as brand awareness, increased user base and sales growth.  


ROI also doesn’t account for context. It fails to consider the noise of the market, which could skew results. Keeping an eye on your competition is crucial as it could have an impact on your marketing actions. Maybe they released a new product or ad at the same time as your launch, which could be eating into your sales intelligence.


Post-campaign reports contain useful information to improve your campaign output, but the problem is they come too late. By the time you receive a post-campaign report, it’s usually months after a project has ended, and because of this it’s difficult to create actionable, impactful decisions based on the intelligence.


Typically, a brand will have already moved onto their next venture by the time they receive these reports, making the recommendations it provides, useless. That’s why real-time intelligence is so important, as it gives brands the power to act reactively, in the moment, to improve their campaign performance, live.  


Social Media metrics can be effective for deducing marketing effectiveness. It all depends on the channel you are using and the goal you are trying to achieve. For example, if you were looking to boost your awareness, you can gauge this through analysis of social metrics, like engagement or reach. But, if you wanted to see the impact that marketing has on your brand and sales, social media will not be able to give conclusive input on this area.  


It’s also incredibly prone to bias, only displaying information users choose to publicly share about themselves. It's important to remember the way a user presents themselves online is often very different to who they normally are, which skews the accuracy of the intelligence you are receiving. Another problem with social media is that only a select group of people use these platforms, making it difficult to target your entire audience at one time, as some of your group may not have accounts.


This means you will need to carry out additional marketing on other platforms to ensure you are reaching your whole target audience, which is another cost for your brand.  


These methods are insubstantial for determining marketing effectiveness, as the intelligence they produce is biased, artificial and surface-level. One of the biggest problems with intelligence today is that it’s backward looking. Brand Managers are forced to constantly look back to see where they went wrong, and because of this they aren’t living in the moment and are missing out on current opportunities.  


This is why real-time intelligence that guides the now is a must-have in the world of Brand Management. It allows brands to be reactive, so if their campaign is heating up, they can keep a finger on the pulse, to ensure they keep momentum. It also provides a way of optimizing campaigns as you go, so if a marketing strategy or creative asset isn’t providing the best results, you can shift onto something more effective before it’s too late.  


Better methods to prove marketing effectiveness  


Marketing effectiveness comes back to the power of a brand. The stronger relationship a brand has with its consumers, the more impactful its marketing actions will be. Brands that cement themselves into people’s lives, making people feel connected and understood, are much more likely to boost their revenue and hit their objectives.  


The traditional methods for deducing marketing effectiveness aren’t conclusive, as they’re outdated and incapable of understanding how people feel about a brand. They can surface the superficial feelings a user reveals about a brand online, but don’t have the capacity to dig deeper into these feelings, to gain a more complex understanding of a brand’s relationship with its consumers.


Chart of customer brand relationship needs


This is because feelings form the basis of relationships, and relationships run the show in Brand Management. All you have to do is look into our ProQuo 16 Drivers to see how fundamental relationships are for brand growth. Every day, we gatherfeelings and thoughtsfrom real peopleto understandhowthey feel about abrand, itscompetition,andits category.


Through the 16 Drivers, we determine the strength of these feelings to identify areas a brand is excelling in, and areas which need more work. Grow these Drivers, and your brand will grow.


How ProQuo proves marketing effectiveness  


ProQuo’s Brand Manager platform liberates brands, making it easier than ever to prove marketing effectiveness. With the platform, Brand Managers can feel confident that their actions or decisions are helping to grow their brand.  


So how does it work? 


Never has it been more important, through the turbulent times of COVID-19, to understand people’s feelings and needs, and stay reactive to respond to these needs. Normally, a brand would put their idea into market and only be able to prove its success months down the line. At this point, it’s too late to do anything with this knowledge. But ProQuo is powered by real-time analysis, meaning you can launch an idea into market and know within minutes whether it’s working.


You can monitor campaigns in real-time, optimize them as you go, and prove the direct impact on your brand. Our platform works tirelessly, around the clock, asking people how they feel about your brand, category and competition, using our tried and tested 16 Drivers. With this intelligence, a brand can understand on a deep level how it’s performing, what’s gone well and what needs to be improved.  


It doesn’t stop there. ProQuo then gives a customized action-plan to harness this intelligence. Set your goals in the platform, and we’ll help you get to your intended result. Looking to disrupt the category? There’ll be a strategy in the platform waiting for you to help you achieve this goal. Every day, you can expect to find custom action-plans suited to your needs, detailing step-by-step what to do to grow your brand.  

 marketing actions and effectiveness


These actions are based on our 14 Marketing Levers, which when pulled, are proven to have an impact on a brand’s growth. Having trouble driving sales? The platform may direct you to our Pricing Lever to decide whether you are valued too high for your target audience, or perhaps you need to create more pricing options to broaden your appeal.  


Before ProQuo, you were forced to rely on outdated metrics when proving marketing effectiveness. Now, you have the option to have a real-time platform that enables you to be reactive, to optimize campaigns and creatives live, and to accurately correlate your brand’s growth with your brand’s actions.  


To discover why ProQuo AI is the future of brand tracking, click here. 


Brand Monitoring eBook dotcom kit - CTA (1)

Previous post
Next post

Subscribe to get our twice monthly newsletter direct to your mailbox

Similar posts you may be interested in

Marketing Cheat Sheet: Kahneman

Brand Management, Brand Strategy

Read more

Marketing Cheat Sheet: Binet and Field

Brand Management, Brand Strategy

Read more

5 tips for Brand Growth from the former CEO of Victoria's Secret

Brand Management, Case Study

Read more